Review of Anthem by Ayn Rand by Robie Cheadle

Published by

on

What Amazon says

Ayn Rand’s classic tale of a dystopian future of the great “We”—a world that deprives individuals of a name or independence—that anticipates her later masterpieces, The Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged.

They existed only to serve the state. They were conceived in controlled Palaces of Mating. They died in the Home of the Useless. From cradle to grave, the crowd was one—the great WE.

In all that was left of humanity there was only one man who dared to think, seek, and love. He lived in the dark ages of the future. In a loveless world, he dared to love the woman of his choice. In an age that had lost all trace of science and civilization, he had the courage to seek and find knowledge. But these were not the crimes for which he would be hunted. He was marked for death because he had committed the unpardonable sin: He had stood forth from the mindless human herd. He was a man alone. He had rediscovered the lost and holy word—I.

“I worship individuals for their highest possibilities as individuals, and I loathe humanity, for its failure to live up to these possibilities.”—Ayn Rand

My review

This book does not have the best plot I have ever read, and neither is it the best written book I have ever read, but it is controversial and makes the reader think. Prior to writing this review I read several of the reviews that had been posted about it. They range from 1-star reviews from people who totally disagree with Ayn Rand’s philosophical viewpoint, to 5-stars from people who have embraced it. For me, a book that results in so much thinking and diverse opinion must be a 5-star read as that is what a book of this nature is all about. It is intended to make the reader think about an extreme social situation.

From a personal perspective, I appreciated the author’s thoughts about a society where everything is for the collective. In many ways it is a lovely thought to have everyone committed to the group as opposed to behaving as individuals, but I firmly believe everyone is different and has different talents, desires, and abilities. Some people are a lot more driven to achieve goals, some of which are for their own financial gain, but there are many people who are driven to achieve personal goals and achieve in areas such as science and maths.  Without the academics and thinkers of this world, we would not progress. Progress requires individuality and creativity as well as single minded dedication and determination. Such people are usually obsessive about their areas of learning. If knowledge and learning were to be discouraged and those with a different way of thinking, spurned, our progressive society would soon faulter and we would start reversing as a society in the manner depicted in this book. H.G. Well’s shared similar thinking in his book, The Time Machine, where the future generation has everything it needs to live a happy life resulting in the people having a diminished intellect from lack of stimulation and behaving like young children.

In this book, the main character is a young man called Equality 7-2521 who is forward thinking and academically inclined. He understands concepts much more quickly than his counterparts and suffers for it in the hands of an intolerant schooling system where being more agile minded than others is discouraged. The MC knows he is different from his peers, but he has never known a society different from the one he lives in where there are no marriages, people do not chose partners but are coupled at the discretion of the leadership, children are raised in communes by people other than their parents and everyone is assigned a job regardless of ability. The book hints at the fact that the MC is assigned to be a street sweeper by the leadership in a deliberate move to suppress him and ensure he could not develop his intellectual abilities. It does not work, and the MC discovers a tunnel under the ground which has the remains of an electric railway line and a sophisticated lightening system.

The MC goes against his upbringing and finds a way to hide in the tunnel and study his findings. This results in him rediscovering electricity. This is a story of a return to a dark age where people are held back in the name of the collective good. It is an extreme view, as mentioned previously, but it is necessary to take that stance to demonstrate the author’s point so effectively.

The plot also includes a romance which is forbidden, and which puts a positive spin on the story and provides the possibility of a future generation of people who are free from the shackles of their narrow-minded society and progress can again take place.

Quote from Anthem by Ayn Rand

“The word «We» is as lime poured over men, which sets and hardens to stone, and crushes all beneath it, and that which is white and that which is black are lost equally in the grey of it. It is the word by which the depraved steal the virtue of the good, by which the weak steal the might of the strong, by which the fools steal the wisdom of the sages.

What is my joy if all hands, even the unclean, can reach into it? What is my wisdom, if even the fools can dictate to me? What is my freedom, if all creatures, even the botched and impotent, are my masters? What is my life, if I am but to bow, to agree and to obey?

But I am done with this creed of corruption.

I am done with the monster of «We,» the word of serfdom, of plunder, of misery, falsehood and shame.

And now I see the face of god, and I raise this god over the earth, this god whom men have sought since men came into being, this god who will grant them joy and peace and pride.

This god, this one word:

«I.”

Purchase Anthem by Ayn Rand

35 respuestas a «Review of Anthem by Ayn Rand by Robie Cheadle»

  1. Avatar de richardbist

    Great review, Robie. I read this book when I was a teen and felt about the same.

    However, it also inspired the rock band, Rush, to create their album 2112. They changed the story, of course, and I think the side-long song is far superior to Rand’s novel.

    Me gusta

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Hi Richard, thank you for this interesting information. I will look up this album. It’s a link I didn’t know about.

      Me gusta

  2. Avatar de Rosie Amber

    Very interesting that reviews are so varied.

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Hi Rosie, any Rand is a controversial author. I celebrate some of her ideas, others I reject but all make me think 💙

      Me gusta

  3. Avatar de beetleypete

    I remember discussing her philosphy at senior school, and I didn’t take to her ideas at the time. I was young, and a very militant left-wing activist, involved in politics at an early age. (16) She was a Conservative thinker and a Republican voter who disagreed with the basic ideals of Socialism. She also testified for the notorious House Committee on Unamerican Activities during the McCarthy purges. I decided I did not want to read her books, and I haven’t changed my mind since then. Shared on Twitter, Robbie.

    Best wishes, Pete.

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Thank you, Pete. She is a controversial author to be sure 💞

      Le gusta a 1 persona

  4. Avatar de ben Alexander

    As a teenager, I remember going on an Ayn Rand tear, and reading more than just several of her books! ❤

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Well done, David. Her books are ‘hard work’ reads and her ideas evoke a strong response whether you agree or disagree.

      Le gusta a 1 persona

  5. Avatar de Annette Rochelle Aben

    My father believed in the «predictive nature» of Ayn Rand’s books. He read them out loud to us once we were old enough to read them for ourselves, much like he read fairy tales to us when we were tiny. The books certainly made me think. I agree about the writing proficiency vs the message (s) thereby creating a compelling reason to give this book (and her others) a read.

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Hi Annette, I like books that make me think and create a strong emotional response in me. Not all the time, but it’s good some of the time.

      Le gusta a 1 persona

  6. Avatar de John W. Howell

    I have always been a fan of Ayn Rand and her ideas around individual effort should be the basis of rewards. I enjoyed your review, Robbie. I also can’t imagine giving a book a one star just because one does not agree with the author’s point. That’s like a giving a one star cause the shipment was late. Thanks. 😊

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Hi John, I suppose giving one star is a way of showing disapproval. Thanks for your comment. The comments on this post are diverse and interesting, just like this author.

      Le gusta a 1 persona

      1. Avatar de John W. Howell

        😁

        Me gusta

  7. Avatar de T. W. Dittmer

    It’s good to read your great review of Anthem by Ayn Rand, Robbie.

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Thank you, Tim

      Le gusta a 1 persona

      1. Avatar de T. W. Dittmer

        My pleasure, Robbie. 😍

        Le gusta a 1 persona

  8. Avatar de Resa

    That was interesting. Thanks Robbie!

    It sounds heavy, so I probably won’t read it, at least this year. I just reread 1984, and have ordered Nobody’s Girl by Virginia Giuffre from the library. These 2 will be enough of hell stories for awhile. Although Virginia Giuffre’s book is a memoir, not fiction.

    I did read Ayn’s first book We the Living and The Fountainhead. I also read about 1/2 of Capitalism: The Unknown Deal. Talk about a dry read!

    Yes, agree or not, she was piquing, stimulating.

    Near the end of the last century, I saw her on a repeat TV talk show (Phil Donahue) from 1980. I watched it, as I had just finished working on a movie about her.

    She was stubborn and argumentative, combative even in her old age. She died in 1982.

    I also thought her group «The Collective» made her look very hypocritical.

    What a terrific happening that you reviewed this book!

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Hi Resa, how interesting to work on a film about Ayn Rand’s life. I never finished The Fountainhead because the weird romance / relationship irritated me. I don’t know if people behave like that – not in my world so it seems unbelievable to me. I do like her ideas so maybe I’ll go back to that book and just live with the romance irritation 😊. 1984 freaked me out completely. That rat scene …

      Le gusta a 2 personas

      1. Avatar de Resa

        Yes, learning about Ayn Rand’s life helped me understand the points she made; agree or disagree.
        Helen Mirren won awards for her portrayal of Ayn.

        1984 is coming true.
        It was freaky enough when I read it 3 decades ago, but as each day passes since Apple released it’s laptop in 1984, we have all watched Orwell’s predictions ring truer and truer.

        The rat scene… terrifying, but I would not be surprised if it is happening in some form now.

        Le gusta a 2 personas

      2. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

        Hi Resa, I am sure that’s torture of prisoners is happening now. I think all governments use that regardless of their political orientation. I hope you are doing okay.

        Le gusta a 1 persona

      3. Avatar de Resa

        Doing fine. Hope you are too!

        Le gusta a 1 persona

      4. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

        Yip. I have news. I’ll email you.

        Le gusta a 1 persona

      5. Avatar de Resa

        Yay..okay!

        Le gusta a 1 persona

  9. Avatar de Liz Gauffreau

    I read Atlas Shrugged years ago. I found it a well-done piece of propaganda. ( I didn’t fall for it.)

    Le gusta a 2 personas

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Hi Liz, another interesting opinion. You have to admit that she gets a reaction out of readers.

      Le gusta a 2 personas

      1. Avatar de Liz Gauffreau

        Yes, she learned her propaganda lessons well!

        Le gusta a 1 persona

  10. Avatar de lyndhurstlaura

    Many thanks for this review, Robbie. This book sounds so controversial that I think I have to read it – and as I just found a free e-copy on Amazon it’s waiting for me on my phone right now. It’s short too, so I can read within a couple of hours. Just what I need to get my reading motivated again! 🙂

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Hi Laura, I look forward to reading your review. I liked that it was short. Long books can start getting me down a bit, especially if their topic is heavy and dystopian.

      Le gusta a 1 persona

  11. Avatar de memadtwo

    What’s interesting to me is that both far right and far left thinking discourages education that questions ideas and curiosity that leads to discovery, demanding unquestioning loyalty to a set of rigid ideas and seeking to punish those who disagree. Life demands both community and individual effort, it’s not an all-or-nothing thing. (K)

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Hi Kerfe, I couldn’t agree with you more. Extremism in any form is negative in my opinion. That includes extreme social reform within short periods. One set of rot is merely replaced by another set.

      Le gusta a 1 persona

  12. Avatar de Miriam Hurdle

    Ayn Rand’s writing surely makes readers think, Robbie! You wrote a fantatic review on it. When I read some people’s one star rating, I often tried to find out what they didn’t like. Their rating shouldn’t be based on where they agree with the author or not.

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Hi Miriam, most of the one star rating don’t have reviews or have a single sentence review. This book can’t be considered in a single sentence. Thanks for commenting.

      Le gusta a 1 persona

  13. Avatar de Author Jan Sikes

    thank you for sharing this book, Robbie. It sounds like good for thought, if nothing more. I am intrigued.

    Le gusta a 1 persona

    1. Avatar de robbiesinspiration

      Hi Jan, definitely food for thought. I can relate to this character as I am bad at conforming. I’m a black sheep 🖤🩶

      Le gusta a 1 persona

Replica a Liz Gauffreau Cancelar la respuesta